Families who hold let property in Spain through several companies have long faced the same obstacle with the tax authorities: the requirement to employ at least one full-time member of staff. Whether that requirement is met determines whether the letting qualifies as a business activity and, in turn, whether the shares can benefit from the Wealth Tax exemption and from the family business reliefs in Inheritance and Gift Tax. In binding ruling V5530-26 of 14 September 2026, the Directorate General for Taxation (DGT) adopts the position set by the Supreme Court earlier this year: the employee may be hired by another company within the group, provided the letting is genuinely integrated into the group’s activity.
Where the requirement comes from
Article 4.Eight.Two of the Wealth Tax Act (Law 19/1991) exempts shares in entities whose main activity is not the management of securities or real estate, and refers to Personal Income Tax rules to decide whether a business activity exists. Under Article 27.2 of the Personal Income Tax Act (Law 35/2006), letting property only counts as a business activity where at least one person is employed under an employment contract, on a full-time basis, to run it.
The DGT has consistently held, in rulings such as V0638-13, V0953-17 and V2513-18, that the contract must qualify as an employment contract under labour law and that the employee must be dedicated exclusively to managing the lettings.
The difficulty lay in the fact that Corporate Income Tax law does contain a group rule. Article 5.1 of the Corporate Income Tax Act provides that, where an entity belongs to a group of companies within the meaning of Article 42 of the Commercial Code, the existence of a business activity is assessed by reference to all the entities in the group. Personal Income Tax law, to which the Wealth Tax refers, has no equivalent provision.
The Supreme Court’s position
Supreme Court judgments 167/2026 of 17 February (appeal 1196/2024) and 186/2026 of 19 February (appeal 1326/2024), handed down in cases concerning gifts of shares in a family business, resolved that tension. Where the letting company belongs to a group carrying on a business activity within the meaning of Article 42 of the Commercial Code and Article 5.1 of the Corporate Income Tax Act, and the lettings are run with the group’s human and material resources, even if these are centralised in other group companies, the employee requirement in Article 27.2 of the Personal Income Tax Act must be regarded as met.
The Court makes this subject to what it calls the decisive criterion: the economic and functional reality of the group must show a unity of resources and activity at group level, and the letting company must be functionally integrated into that activity, serving it rather than merely using its resources. Formal membership of the group is not enough; in that case the requirement must be met by the letting company on its own.
The judgments add a point of particular relevance to holding structures. Where those conditions are met, the holding company’s shares in the letting subsidiary are business assets and are not treated as non-business assets under the proportionality rule in the last paragraph of Article 4.Eight.Two of the Wealth Tax Act.
What ruling V5530-26 adds
The taxpayer owned 100% of several companies engaged in letting property and asked whether the requirement could be met by a person employed by any one of them. The DGT reproduces the Supreme Court’s doctrine and accepts it, with a caveat that should not be overlooked: whether there is unity of resources and activity at group level, and whether the letting company is functionally integrated, are questions of fact on which the DGT will not express a general view. They are to be assessed, where appropriate, by the competent tax authority in the course of a tax audit.
The ruling therefore confirms the principle but provides no safe harbour. The burden of evidencing integration will rest with the taxpayer whenever the exemption is challenged.
A point the ruling leaves open
The Supreme Court framed its doctrine around groups within the meaning of Article 42 of the Commercial Code, a provision that defines a group by reference to the control exercised by a parent company. In the case submitted, however, the companies were not held through a holding company but directly by an individual, and the ruling does not consider whether sister companies controlled by the same individual shareholder form a group for these purposes.
This is not a minor point. Where the legislator has wished to extend the concept of a group to entities controlled by individuals, it has said so expressly, as in Article 101.3 of the Corporate Income Tax Act for the small company regime; Article 5.1 contains no such extension. In the firm’s view, structures without a parent company call for specific analysis before the exemption is claimed on the strength of the group criterion alone.
Practical scope
The effect goes beyond the Wealth Tax. The Inheritance and Gift Tax reliefs on transfers of family business shares (Article 20, sections 2.c) and 6, of Law 29/1987) are conditional on the Wealth Tax exemption under Article 4.Eight.Two, and so are the regional improvements built upon it. The classification of the letting activity therefore shapes both the annual tax position and succession planning.
To rely on this criterion, evidence of functional integration should be built in advance and in writing. That means a real, centralised organisation of resources, with staff functions described and verifiable; intragroup service agreements covering the management of the lettings, priced in line with the related party rules; common management and decision making that can be demonstrated; and genuine business activity by the group as a whole. A payroll held in a different company, without that structure, is unlikely to withstand an audit.
Final remarks
Ruling V5530-26 confirms at administrative level a criterion that relaxes a requirement traditionally applied with rigidity, but it moves the debate onto the ground of evidence. In family structures with several property companies, common in the Balearic Islands, it is advisable to review in good time how the properties are managed, which company bears the resources and how integration is documented, before the exemption is questioned in an audit or on a transfer.
At Lex·on we review these structures case by case, both when assessing the Wealth Tax exemption and when planning the transfer of a family business.
If your family holds assets in the Balearic Islands, Tramuntana Tax, the international desk run by the same partners, explains inheritance and gift tax in the Balearic Islands.
Sources: Binding ruling V5530-26 of 14 September 2026, Spanish Directorate General for Taxation; Supreme Court judgments 167/2026 of 17 February (appeal 1196/2024) and 186/2026 of 19 February (appeal 1326/2024).
© Lexon Advisory, S.L.U. All rights reserved. The total or partial reproduction of this content, by any means or procedure, without the express written authorisation of its owner is prohibited. Any unauthorised use will constitute an infringement of intellectual property rights under applicable law.
This article is for information purposes only and reflects the administrative position in force on the date of publication. It does not constitute legal or tax advice and does not replace an individual analysis of each case.