Sale of a Spanish property by a non-resident company: the TEAC rules on acquisition cost, depreciation and furniture. Decision of the Central Economic-Administrative Court (TEAC) of 24 September 2026 (RG 00/07794/2023)

The decision of the TEAC, Spain’s central administrative tax tribunal, of 24 September 2026 concerns the sale of a house in Spain by a French civil company (société civile) and is particularly instructive for non-residents who hold Spanish property through companies. The company had reported a capital loss of €89,311.56 in its Non-Resident Income Tax return and claimed a refund of the 3% withholding. Following a limited review, the National Tax Management Office set the acquisition cost at €104,492.42, against the €482,459.12 declared, and issued an assessment for €48,950.70 including late payment interest. The TEAC upholds the assessment in substance and corrects it on a single point.

The facts

The majority shareholder bought two plots of land in 2008 for €120,000 and contracted, in her own name, the construction of a house for €320,000. The works were completed in May 2010. In October that year she incorporated the company, holding 99% of the capital, with the remaining 1% held by her spouse, and in November she sold the property to it for €103,448.28. The deed declaring the new building stated that the company owned the plot and had carried out the construction.

In May 2022 the company sold the property for €450,000, of which the deed allocated €25,000 to furniture. In computing the gain, the company included €356,036.63 of construction costs in the acquisition cost and deducted the furniture from the sale price, arriving at a loss.

First issue: which costs the company can claim

Article 24.4 of the consolidated Non-Resident Income Tax Act refers to Personal Income Tax rules for computing the capital gains of non-residents without a permanent establishment. Under Article 35 of the Personal Income Tax Act, the acquisition cost comprises the actual purchase price, together with the cost of investments and improvements and the expenses and taxes inherent in the purchase, borne by the acquirer.

The TEAC refuses to include the building costs. The evidence showed that the shareholder had contracted and paid for the construction, which was completed before the company existed. The deed does not alter that conclusion: under Article 319 of the Civil Procedure Act and Article 1218 of the Civil Code, a notarial deed proves the act it records and its date, but not the truth of the parties’ statements or the price stated in it. The TEAC refers to its earlier decisions of 18 December 2023 (RG 00/05213/2020) and 19 November 2024 (RG 00/03308/2021): the value of building works must be evidenced by invoices and payment records showing that the works were carried out, that they amount to improvements, what they cost and that they were paid for by whoever claims them.

The argument that market value should apply, since this was a related party transaction, also fails. Article 35 refers to the actual amount of the acquisition, not to market value, so the company’s acquisition cost is what it paid for the property. The TEAC reiterates that shareholder and company are separate persons and that blurring their assets cannot be relied on to obtain a higher acquisition cost.

The practical consequence is clear: the form and price at which a property enters a company set its future tax cost. Whatever the shareholder invested before contributing or selling it does not pass to the company merely because a deed says so. How that transfer is structured, with its implications for the transferor and for indirect taxes, needs to be analysed at the time of the transaction rather than on sale.

Second issue: minimum depreciation

Article 35 also requires the acquisition cost to be reduced by depreciation that was tax deductible. The National Tax Management Office took the view that a legal person cannot itself occupy a house, so the property must have been let to third parties or made available to the shareholders throughout the period of ownership, a use that Article 12 of the Non-Resident Income Tax Act presumes to be remunerated unless proven otherwise. On that basis it applied cumulative minimum depreciation of €17,438.74 over 4,191 days.

The TEAC, applying a criterion it repeats in another decision of the same date (RG 00/08201/2023), holds that the authority was presuming a fact giving rise to a tax charge and therefore bore the burden of proving it; the file contained no direct or indirect evidence of any letting or use. However, the company itself had asked in its submissions for depreciation to be calculated over 1,500 days. The TEAC treats that request as an admission that the property was made available for that period and sets depreciation on the basis of 1,500 days.

This is the only point on which the claim succeeds, and its financial effect is limited. What matters is the warning it carries: what a taxpayer argues may be treated as an admission of fact, and a poorly framed alternative argument can supply the evidence the authority had not produced.

Third issue: furniture in the sale deed

The company sought to reduce the sale price by the €25,000 allocated to furniture. The TEAC rejects this: the deed proves the sale and its date, but not that part of the price actually related to furniture. Separate treatment would have required evidence of the purchase of the furniture, its actual transfer and a valuation independent of that of the property.

The TEAC endorses the reasoning of the tax office, which is worth knowing. If furniture is deducted from the sale price, consistency requires deducting from the purchase price the furniture already in place on acquisition; and since furniture loses value with use, its value on sale will rarely exceed its value on purchase unless later acquisitions are proven. The tax office also observes that such clauses are commonly included in sales by non-residents so that part of the price escapes tax in Spain without later being declared in the country of residence, and it weighed against the company that no tax return from its state of residence reporting that sale was produced.

One further observation, not addressed in the decision: the withholding applied, €12,750, is exactly 3% of the €425,000 allocated to the property. Where the furniture allocation does not hold, its effect on the withholding the buyer must apply under Article 25.2 of the Non-Resident Income Tax Act should also be reviewed.

Practical conclusions

The decision offers three useful guidelines for non-resident companies, and their shareholders, planning to sell a property in Spain. The acquisition cost only includes what the company itself paid and can support with invoices in its name and proof of payment; statements in a deed do not replace that evidence. The use of the property during ownership affects the computation of the gain, and any position taken in the proceedings must be weighed carefully. Finally, allocating part of the price to furniture will only withstand scrutiny if there is an inventory, evidence of purchase, a reasonable valuation and consistency with what is reported in the country of residence.

At Lex·on we review the documentation for these sales and the computation of the gain in advance, so that Form 210 and any claim for a refund of the withholding are filed with the support the Spanish tax authorities will expect.

If you are a non-resident preparing to sell a home in Mallorca, Tramuntana Tax, the international desk run by the same partners, explains the 3% withholding on the sale of a Mallorca home.

Source: Decision of the Central Economic-Administrative Court (TEAC) of 24 September 2026 (RG 00/07794/2023).
© Lexon Advisory, S.L.U. All rights reserved. The total or partial reproduction of this content, by any means or procedure, without the express written authorisation of its owner is prohibited. Any unauthorised use will constitute an infringement of intellectual property rights under applicable law.
This article is for information purposes only and reflects the administrative position in force on the date of publication. It does not constitute legal or tax advice and does not replace an individual analysis of each case.